Theories Discussion > General Discussion

Quarreling among the men hikers

<< < (2/5) > >>

Loose}{Cannon:
Or....  Could be of a huge importance.    50/50

sarapuk:

--- Quote from: Loose}{Cannon on August 12, 2019, 12:31:06 PM ---Or....  Could be of a huge importance.    50/50

--- End quote ---

So huge that they all decided to leave the safety of their Tent and risk DEATH ETC ETC.

Star man:
Have done some research into this as part of the topic I started on “simplest possible credible explanation “

Ask yourself this question.  If some kind of quarrel broke out that was so bad that they would leave their life boat “the tent “ and risk their lives or even try to kill each other - why didn’t they use knives?  There are no stab wounds  and certainly nobody died from stabbing or cuts and loss of blood.

There is evidence that they engaged in punching and kicking from the state of their hands - so if they had weapons why not use them on each other ?  They did use the knives to cut cedar and fir tree branches and clothes from their dead friends but not on each other.

Interestingly enough the knife that the rav 4 had was never found. 

My view is that the knife could well have been used in self defence and walked off stuck in whatever it was that killed them.

Regards
Star man

Loose}{Cannon:
Not every scuffle turns into a gun fight. 

Star man:

--- Quote from: Loose}{Cannon on August 14, 2019, 06:06:54 AM ---Not every scuffle turns into a gun fight.

--- End quote ---

That is true.  In the Dyatlov case though we would be talking about a scuffle that ultimately led to their demise.  As the events unfolded the group would know the dangers.  So if it was a basic scuffle then they would not likely choose to leave the tent for that reason.  I can only envisage them leaving the tent without the proper clothing and equipment if it was not just a basic scuffle but something much more serious and life threatening.  In that case if they were fighting each other why would they not use weapons?  IMO they were a team and if they were fighting it is much more likely it was some other foe.

Regards
Star man

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page

There was an error while thanking
Thanking...
Go to full version