September 25, 2022, 05:02:47 PM
Dyatlov Pass Forum

Author Topic: Except for the diary, except for one backpack...  (Read 147 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

August 24, 2022, 11:52:02 AM
Read 147 times
Online

Charles


We can read in the protocol of camp site finding:

28.02.59 the prosecutor city of Ivdel Jr Counselor of Justice Tempalov in the presence of witnesses: comrade Maslennikov and Brusnitsin Vadim Dmitriyevich living in Sverdlovsk, Sheynkmana St № III, room 31, Sharavin Mihail Petrovich living in Sverdlovsk, Vtuzgorodok, housing 9, room № 201, Kurikov Stepan Nikolaevich living in Ivdel region village Suevat Paun (Paul - ed.), have written this report upon finding the place where Dyatlov group of hikers stayed overnight.

Camp site is located on the northeast slope of mountain 1079 at the source of Auspiya river. The camp site site is located 300 meters from the top of the mountain 1079 on a slope of 30°. The campsite is a snow-leveled area with 8 pairs of skis at the bottom. The tent is stretched out on ski poles, fixed with ropes, 9 backpacks with various personal belongings of the group members were laid down at the bottom of the tent, quilted jackets, storm jackets were put on top, 9 pairs of felt boots were found where the heads must have been, men's trousers were also found, and three pairs of felt boots, warm fur coats, socks, hat, ski caps, utensils, buckets, stove, ax, saw, blankets, food: biscuits in two bags, condensed milk, sugar, concentrates, notebooks, itinerary and many other small items and documents, camera and accessories to a camera. All items found were transferred for an inventory and delivery to ... base chief search group Evgeniy Maslennikov Polikarpovich for which this protocol was drawn up. There are no bodies found in the tent.

Attorney city of Ivdel
Jr Counselor of Justice / Tempalov /
Witnesses:
1) Brusnitsin
2) Sharavin
3) Kurikov
The head of the unit
4) Maslennikov

(https://dyatlovpass.com/case-files-2?rbid=17743)

But we can read the following in Georgiy Vladimirovich Atmanaki about his discovery of the tent on February 26:

Together with two people from Slobtsov team and the guides, Borisov and I combed the slope lower and to the right of the tent (if we look down) meeting on the way two Mansi and a comrade of a paramilitary type, who later turned out to be the chief of the Ivdel fire brigade. They told us that they found two bodies 2 km down and showed us where the tent is located. Going up we observed traces that were going down and belonging, as it later turned out, to the dead hikers. Several pairs of other tracks belonged to the participants of the search parties who were working the day before. There were no other tracks or objects on this site, except for a roll of film about 15 m below the tent, which rolled out from there during the preliminary inspection of the tent the day before. All remained undisturbed except for one backpack in which small things were gathered around the tent. They did not make a detailed inspection of the tent, because they explained that they were afraid to see their comrades in it. The tent stood sideways to the slope by the entrance to the east, the entrance was unbuttoned but piled in half with buckets, stove and backpacks, so that at first there was an impression that people tried to barricade the entrance by stacking the corner of the tent with a load so that it will not be torn by the wind. The tent was laid on skis, straps were tied to ski poles, and most of them were not damaged. On the slope of the tent we found a flashlight, an ice ax not far away down, there was a pair of skis stuck in the snow, the windy (north) side of the tent was torn and some blankets and a quilted jacket were protruding out. The other side of the tent was heaped with bulging snow and lay on the bottom of the tent, overlaying all the contents in it. Before we started the search we decided to check if there was anyone left in the tent. Snow was removed, the fallen side of the tent was raised, and we carefully removed the blankets and quilted jackets. There were no people in the tent. Inspected the contents. The bottom of the tent lay on skis, then quilted jackets, backpacks, gaiters and other small equipment. Towards the heads on the south side were felt boots and boots, in the far right corner we found a field bag with the documents of the group, a box of films and money, a camera and a few small objects, everything was packed in a backpack, except for the diary and documents sent to the base camp. There was no point to continue the further dismantling of the things, and so they left everything into place before the investigator arrived, after raising the tent and pulling out three pairs of skis, because dog guides went on foot, and the rest of the skis were used by us to mark the places where the bodies of the dead were found.
(https://dyatlovpass.com/case-files-209-220)

In the first testimony, all 9 backpacks were laid down at the bottom of the tent under jackets but in the second testimony, some of the backpacks were piled at the entrance. And there is an ambiguity about "All remained undisturbed except for one backpack in which small things were gathered around the tent": was this backpack taken from the tent and used to collect the small things (as the rescuers took skis belonging to the hikers: "pulling out three pairs of skis, because dog guides went on foot")? And one diary was treated differently, the diary of "except for the diary". And this one special diary was removed "before the investigators arrived".

These inconsistencies and ambiguities allow us to think that the tent was searched before the arrival of the investigators and that one diary was treated differently.

Either one of the two protocols is outrageously incorrect: counting all the 9 backpacks at the bottom vs noticing some of the backpacks piled up at the entry, or the backpacks were searched and moved between the two events, the two protocols correctly reporting a change about the backpacks positions - but in that case all didn't remain "undisturbed except for one backpack": all remained undisturbed except for the few backpacks piled up at the entrance.

« Last Edit: August 24, 2022, 04:38:11 PM by Charles »
 

August 24, 2022, 07:46:05 PM
Reply #1
Offline

Ziljoe


Hi Charles,

I'm a bit confused as you seemed to have edited your first post, which I'm sure you said they took SEMYON ZOLOTARYOV  diary?
 

August 25, 2022, 01:24:21 AM
Reply #2
Online

Charles


Hello Ziljoe,

the first diary to be recovered seemed to be "group's diary", at the bottom of the tent... so just remains here the strange question of the backpacks.

I couldn't find when and how the different diaries were recovered.
 

September 06, 2022, 03:48:32 PM
Reply #3
Offline

sarapuk

Case-Files Achievement Recipient
Hello Ziljoe,

the first diary to be recovered seemed to be "group's diary", at the bottom of the tent... so just remains here the strange question of the backpacks.

I couldn't find when and how the different diaries were recovered.


If you search the Forum you will find the info you are looking for. Bear in mind that there are things missing from the investigation. The investigation started with the demise of the Dyatlov Group in 1959 and continues.
DB