Dyatlov Pass Forum

Theories Discussion => General Discussion => Topic started by: Osi on October 07, 2026, 02:11:08 PM

Title: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Osi on October 07, 2026, 02:11:08 PM
For a slab avalanche to occur, a sufficient amount of fresh snow (30 cm or more)—heavy enough to trigger a sliding motion—must have fallen. The terrain slope must be suitable, and the area must be free of trees or major surface irregularities. Slab avalanches typically occur during or immediately after fresh snowfall, usually within a day at most. As time passes, the factors causing instability between the fresh snow and the underlying snowpack diminish; the layers bond together, and no avalanche occurs. Other triggering conditions are also significant: following snowfall, temperatures may rise suddenly, or conversely, strong winds may begin to blow. Additionally, a skier or a shovel could cut into the snow mass and set it in motion. In the vicinity of Kholat, it is virtually impossible to encounter an avalanche event without a combination of heavy snowfall, meteorological factors (such as a sudden rise in temperature or strong winds), and human intervention.
In light of the data regarding slab avalanches described above, a possible explanation for the tragedy emerges: the final days of January had been quite calm until the Dyatlov group reached the slopes of Kholat. However, it is evident that the weather deteriorated starting February 1st; with the onset of fresh snowfall, the previously relatively easy traverse across the Auspiya plain became impossible. It became necessary to lighten their loads, and they attempted to follow a new route along the ridgeline before entering the forest.
Upon waking on the morning of February 1st, they noticed the fresh snowfall and waited for it to stop. The precipitation did not cease until midday. They set out without wasting any more time, leaving some of their equipment behind. In the afternoon, the snowfall intensified, forcing them to halt. They planned to spend the night on the slope and reach the summit of Otorten—a day's hike away—the following morning. Given that the snowfall, which had lasted all day, intensified after the tent was pitched (continuing from the 5:00 PM setup until 8:00 PM), it is evident that the two conditions necessary for a slab avalanche were met: a sufficient amount of snow had accumulated, and the natural anchor points holding the snow mass in place had been disrupted by human activity. That leaves meteorological factors. It would have been unrealistic to expect a rise in temperature on the slopes of Kholat at that time of year and day; a strong wind had likely sprung up. Indeed, it must have been a powerful wind that caused the group's tent to collapse under a slab avalanche, disrupted their progress through the forest, and prevented them from returning to the tent.
This scenario is the most consistent version regarding the unfolding and consequences of the Dyatlov tragedy. Naturally, it requires supporting evidence. If there had been no snowfall—or only very light precipitation—on the day the tent was pitched or the following days, the snow would have been blown away by the wind, and the tent fabric would have been found clean. Yet, there was approximately 20 cm of snow on the tent. In the photos showing the tent's setup, we see the tourists cutting into the snowpack—which reaches waist-height—to create a level platform and a wall directly in front of them. Yet, in the images taken when the tent was actually found, we see neither the debris from that excavation nor a tent embedded within a meter-high snow wall. It appears as though the tent was simply placed on the slope without any ground leveling. If we accept these photos as a valid reference—assuming the group members used sleds to dig through fresh snow and cut into the older, hard snow to reach that waist-deep level before lining up their sleds—then perhaps a slab avalanche swept away the fresh snow layer (which had accumulated to 30 cm, and later 50–60 cm, by the time the tent was pitched), leaving the tent exposed on the much harder snowpack from December or January. If the tent shows no signs of external interference, the most plausible reason for it being cut open and abandoned is that conditions inside made it impossible to stay there—such as a heavy weight pressing down that made re-entering and breathing impossible. They exited the tent and walked calmly downhill. They placed a lit flashlight on the tent's peak—which remained relatively exposed above the snow cover—and left another one along the path leading to the forest. This suggests the incident occurred early in the night; the plan was likely for some group members to descend to the forest and then return, using the flashlight beams to navigate and retrieve extra equipment from the tent. The flares signal that there is no human threat influencing their decision to return to the tent, that they have experienced a natural disaster, and that they have injured people who need to be urgently brought down to the forest.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 07, 2026, 04:25:56 PM
Yes, that is one of the reasons why I do not agree with the slab avalanche theory. We need to determine whether the phenomenon that caused the evacuation of the tent was the same as the one involved in the events further down the slope. So, why did they head in the opposite direction from Labaz—and against the freezing winds? (What kind of drive and determination motivates people to venture into the darkness and the unknown?)
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 07, 2026, 06:23:59 PM
They were on a slope. The slope led,to trees. Trees are shelter, firewood and a snow cave. No other decision produces the same risk to reward.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 07, 2026, 07:24:12 PM
Yes, and even with the lantern in your hands, they decided to go northeast towards the slope (They walked in the direction against the freezing winds). They chose an unknown route when they could have gone to Labaz, which was a closer route (south)
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ziljoe on October 07, 2026, 08:00:29 PM
I'm not sure if the labaz was the closest route or the wind direction . There are several things to negotiate by returning to the labaz and altitude might be one. The tree line might have been visible from the tent and finding the tent again would be easier from the cedar area. Everything is still in line of sight .
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Osi on October 07, 2026, 08:03:42 PM
The Labaz contained only food. This indicates that they had no issues regarding nutrition. The labaz was located 2 to 2.5 kilometers away, and the route to it involved ups and downs; I do not believe they could have found it in the dark. Had they all emerged from the tent intact, I am absolutely certain that one of them—despite the potential risk of a secondary threat—would have gone back through that same opening to retrieve some clothing and boots. They were people accustomed to traveling in temperatures of 15 to 20 degrees below zero; even with the temperature at -20°C, they could have descended directly toward the forest—a trek taking no more than 20 minutes—and then built a fire. For Russians accustomed to the cold, that is a manageable timeframe. I attribute the decision to forgo retrieving clothing and boots from the tent to the fact that they had multiple companions suffering from trauma who required immediate assistance.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 08, 2026, 09:23:53 AM
Let’s consider this: even if they weren't heading to Labaz, they could have chosen a different direction. We know they had two flashlights and that one was either lost along the way or discarded. We also know they had previously traveled the southern route—specifically, in late January. So, even if they weren't going to Labaz, they should have headed in another direction. As it turned out, the area they entered was the worst possible choice; they took an unfamiliar route—and, worse yet, moved against the wind on a freezing night. Incidentally, Labaz held not only food but also other gear, including felt boots. So, the question remains: what made them choose the worst possible route?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Osi on October 08, 2026, 10:35:42 AM
The direction they headed leads to a sheltered, hollow valley—the spot closest to the tent where they could find firewood. In every other direction, as well as along the northern ridge, the terrain is bare, treeless, and exposed to the wind. There is no need to go to the cache just to retrieve a pair of boots or some food; the idea of ​​visiting the cache only makes sense once it becomes clear that the tent is lost for good. Had I been able to look out at the forest from the tent in daylight, I would have reckoned on a twenty-minute descent, followed by a ten-minute task of gathering fuel to get a fire going. A village in plain sight needs no guide.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Hunter on October 08, 2026, 11:02:30 AM
Judging by the group's diaries and photographs, the sleds were not used by the group for long, as they proved to be extremely impractical for transporting cargo.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 08, 2026, 11:33:03 AM
I think the answer you gave me is partly good, but it oversimplifies a crucial aspect. It doesn't necessarily rule out my objection. Heading toward the nearest forest makes sense as a survival strategy, but it doesn't fully explain why that specific direction was chosen—in that particular way and at that specific moment. I’d argue that this actually strengthens an argument against the original hypothesis. It’s not simply a matter of "they didn't go to Labaz"; the issue is that, in a dire emergency, they chose that exact path. The point isn't whether there was a better route available. It’s about why they chose a direction that was seemingly exposed and against the wind, despite knowing the area to the south. So I ask: what could have led them to believe that walking against the wind, in the dark, toward an unknown area was the best option at that moment? I have my own theory, but I’d like to hear more from you.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Osi on October 08, 2026, 11:53:11 AM
What led you to conclude that the wind was blowing from the direction of the cedar tree and the valley? Typically, regardless of the direction from which Ural winds originate, they strike the mountain slopes at high altitudes and descend down the ridge. The snow on the peaks is sparser and has a hardened crust, as it is constantly swept down into the valley; consequently, all the Ural ridges are bare. They made their descent with the wind at their backs. If we categorize the tent's location according to the four cardinal directions: the north side is a bare ridge; the east side is a bare, forested ridge extending toward Otorten; and the west side—the direction from which they arrived—leads down to the Auspiya Valley via an undulating, exposed path. Naturally, the south is the ideal direction, as it is closest to the tree line.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 08, 2026, 11:58:25 AM
Yes, you are absolutely right; heading south is the ideal choice. But they didn't go there—they went in the worst possible direction
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Osi on October 08, 2026, 12:20:44 PM
So, where do you think they were supposed to go barefoot? Take a short break at the "Boot Rock" a kilometer away and descend the pass to Auspiya, cross the bare ridge they intended to attempt in the morning to reach Otorten, or climb Peak 1079 behind them?
(https://i.ibb.co/XR0R2WM/MG-20261008-223404.avif) (https://ibb.co/7mMmYSL)
3When I draw a circle with a one-mile radius centered on the tent and divide it into six pie-shaped slices, I can access the forest and valley only from the tip of the slice facing the cedar tree and the valley; the other slices consist of vast, barren expanses, elevations, and rugged terrain.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 08, 2026, 01:01:52 PM
or assume that what made them go down the slope made the choice of direction irrelevant?


(https://i.ibb.co/LdSs9JWc/Sasha-Ivanov.png) (https://imgbb.com/)

unlimited image hosting (https://pt.imgbb.com/)
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 08, 2026, 01:09:49 PM
Are you just looking at which sector gives faster access to the forest, or are you also considering the survivors' thermal exposure during the move?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 08, 2026, 01:14:15 PM
I suppose two things drove their decision. First, they would want heat.I believe they saw and moved toward a cedar which at the edge of the forest was conspicuous by its size. Perhaps it was a woodcraft skil but cedar is more flammable than wet fir. Secondly, they may have reasoned that erecting a lean to for nine was inferior to a cave for nine. That would require either finding a cornice or snow deep enough to tunnel into. My reasoning for thinking this is because first of all it happened and secondly, no investigator then or now has proposed another option.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 08, 2026, 01:22:50 PM
If they were just looking for a heat source, cedar is a possible explanation. But if the immediate priority was to find shelter, the presence of a specific tree by itself doesn't explain the choice of direction.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 08, 2026, 01:32:56 PM
The snow settling in creeks and ravines is considerable deeper than ice and rockbound conditions in the ridge. Case file photos support this. The DP9 required heat and shelter, it is up to any of us to imagine what they prioritized.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 08, 2026, 01:59:02 PM
I believe the first thing they did when they came down the slope was to build Zolotarev's den
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 08, 2026, 03:30:55 PM
Ramsay, a very senior member of the forum is also inclined to support that idea. Now think this through. First, what environmental cues would prompt excavating in any location as opposed to any other? Next, was the excavation going to accommodate nine people? Next, was it all hands on deck digging, or were some assigned for forage for cut branches to get them off the ground where they sat? Next, when do you believe the garment remnants were obtained that were found on the mat in the den?

Finally, appreciate that none of the activities involved in protecting the R4 ( and perhaps the whole DP0 group, requires any additional conspiracy theory to explain it. This is a group of intelligent people doing their best to get out of the cold, nothing more.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 08, 2026, 05:13:30 PM
Glenn, I have my own theory about what happened to the Dyatlov group. You can read about it later. Since I believe the official theory is flawed, I base my opinion on what I've formulated, which you can read later. But this topic isn't about my theory, so I'll tell you that what happened down the slope was a survival operation ordered by Zolotarev. The idea was to build a shelter for everyone initially. So while the three from the ravine were engaged in the excavation, the first collapse occurred. Then the remaining six reorganized for the rescue. It's all there. No UFOs or portals. Kolevatov went to get the clothes from the cedar tree.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 08, 2026, 05:26:14 PM
Very good. We have Lyidas position and the branch mat to figure in. Is it your idea that Zolo and others dug in keeping to the side by following the stream, or did they find a bare spot between treelined stream banks and reasoned they could dig straight down until they hit ground and then excavated in a direction? How would they get in and out of the hole? Since Lyuda and Zolo had similar type of injuries, do you feel she too was a digger?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 08, 2026, 05:33:58 PM
I think it largely depends on the nature of the ravine and what it was like that night. Digging near the River might be helpful for geographical orientation. Near the river you have easy access to mineral water, and boiling it is also less difficult. The Red Army scouts recommended: "Never camp above the forest line if you can descend 500m".
The snow near the river is deeper and fluffier, so you can dig a hole more easily, and you have thermal insulation.
At first everyone was working at the den, but Zolotarev, Lyuda, and Thibo were working inside.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 09, 2026, 06:22:46 AM

(https://i.ibb.co/vxwfz623/5.png) (https://ibb.co/fY1Z0zmk)

(https://i.ibb.co/cjdfycZ/4.png) (https://ibb.co/pSpV1vM)

(https://i.ibb.co/JWqW3R7b/1.png) (https://ibb.co/RGNGjp0M)
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 09, 2026, 11:56:16 AM
So, what makes you think the bodies were found in a different place from where the wooden platform was?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Axelrod on October 09, 2026, 12:18:59 PM
So, what makes you think the bodies were found in a different place from where the wooden platform was?
I don't understand the reason for the outcry—after all, the bodies were found in a different location.
The platform was discovered first, and there were no bodies on it.
The bodies were found later, off to the side—as shown in the pictute—and further downstream.
The report states a distance of 6 meters; it might have been 4 meters.
Either way, that is the length of a room.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 09, 2026, 01:30:38 PM
Yes, I know that. Everyone explains it in their own way, others ignore the fact. I have my idea, but what's your explanation?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 09, 2026, 01:50:39 PM
What's going on here is that the original poster disbelieves the facts in the case files. The idea being that someone with much to gain had intervened and obfuscated everything by creating red herrings, or false facts.
Consequently, this person can not be reasoned with because there is no common ground. Typical ofmthese types of exchanges is that the person who discounts the factual evidence offers nothing to replace it, rather they mildly insult the intelligence by saying, are you not smart enough to see it for yourself? It is an umproductive, provocarive attempt promote another conspiracy theory by indirect intimidation. They are best ignored.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Osi on October 12, 2026, 03:32:40 AM
The fact that two flashlights were found outside the tent—despite other vital equipment being left inside—is evidence that both flashlights had been actively used within the tent. Had the flashlights merely been stashed away while turned off, it would have been impossible to locate them beneath the collapsed snow.
Let us assume they pitched their tents on the crusty snow that had fallen prior to the final camp. This type of snow is dry and crystallized; stepping on it causes the snow to crumble, preventing the formation of distinct imprints that would reveal whether one was walking in military socks, barefoot, or in *valenki* (felt boots). This holds true even with 10 cm of fresh snow, as the wind would disperse such a light layer within hours. The tracks that actually exist were formed by trampling through much deeper fresh snow. While the snow was significantly deeper at the valley mouth—where they entered the forest—one would expect to see deep, 50–60 cm post-hole footprints there; yet, none exist. This indicates the following: there was a substantial amount of fresh snow that night. The area containing the tracks was a zone of wind-blown snow, whereas the valley entrance—where the tracks vanished—was the zone where snow blown from above accumulated. Part of the snow cover in this area consisted of wind-blown debris from the avalanche that had been triggered by the accumulation of snow on the tent.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 12, 2026, 08:09:56 AM
Osi, good comment. Can we make an argument that flashlights would be kept by those who had guard duty? Is it reasonable that anyone who had guard duty would be more fully dressed than others? I think it reasonable. I think Tibo and Zolo are good candidates for that.

I am going to hang on to my idea that Igor came up lame the day before and did not lead the down hill evacuation, but could have dictated the course from his discussion with Rempel. Pure guess, of course.

I also add that if given a choice of pitching a tent on bare, rock/icy ground or finding a snow filled hollow, the team would choose the hollow. This means that on 1079, the hikers stopped at a place where they could make an L cut in a snow bank to level their tent and put a foundation of skis on a pad of snow and not bare earth.

Of course this L cut figures highly in the collapse of the snow bank onto the tent and everything else that followed.

The discovery of the flashlight on the tent is baffling. I can find no reason for the hikers not to take it with them. It was within arm's reach, I think. I do not think it was of much use in illuminating their efforts to leave the scene. The best I can come up with is that it, like the snow axe was left outside the tent for after dark potty breaks.
I must believe it was tethered, perhaps to a ski pole and hung outside so as not to roll away. If so, then I can more easily imagine snow both above and below it when discovered.

The various depths and textures of the snow say to me that over days and weeks the local conditions resulted in what the rescuers observed.

Good post Osi.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 12, 2026, 08:23:28 AM
Good observation, Osi. I actually agree with GlennM about the lanterns; they were with Zolotarev and Thibo, who I believe were outside the tent. They took it with them when the evacuation was ordered. I believe the characteristic footprints in the snow (which some even argue are "boot prints" or "running footprints") can be explained by a kind of orderly and cohesive march during the evacuation of the ravine, which, in my opinion, was led by Zolotarev.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Osi on October 12, 2026, 08:57:36 AM
Wearing multiple pairs of socks layered over one another was not a preferred practice while on the move, due to the risk of them getting wet and the discomfort of constriction.


Generally, this method was used only while sleeping at night. The ambient light reflected off the snow provided sufficient visibility, so I do not believe flashlights were used for navigation.

 While flashlights are certainly useful for bathroom trips during summer forest camps, they had to be used for a short while that night to arrange sleeping positions and put on socks and *valenki* (felt boots). To create raised footprints or leave sock-patterned impressions in the snow, one must tread upon fresh, moist snow. We know these raised tracks stood 15 to 20 centimeters high. What amount of snow needs to be trampled to produce such high tracks? I estimate a ratio of 1 to 5—meaning a depth of 50 or 60 centimeters of fresh snow in the area where the tracks were found. That snow was completely blown away by the wind later that night and the following day.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 12, 2026, 06:23:08 PM
In connection with the re-examination of the case in 2019, official scientific expert opinions were prepared, which try to describe the climatic conditions of the period February 1-2, 1959 for the snow slope of the tent and the surroundings of the cedar; also the estimation of visibility; and the probability of a possible avalanche.

In addition, in 2021, Swiss scientists who had never been to the site, for some reason also developed a theory about slab-avalanche with the help of snow simulation software made for a Disney cartoon (which they downloaded illegally from the Internet).

Based on these, only 10 millimeters of snow fell on the spot during the indicated period, and not 30 centimeters, which you consider necessary for the avalanche. However, unlike you, these expert opinions consider it possible to develop an avalanche even in such conditions. And the visibility was only 16 meters. (which means that by moving 30-50 meters away from the tent, they would have found their way back to it only by following their footprints)

It is important to take into account that there are no meteorological data from the area determined by measurement from the time of the incident, only from distances of 50-100 km. Although experts can draw nice graphs in the documentation, but the data that the graphs show are based on speculation and have a lot of uncertainty.

Regarding the avalanche, other, unofficial, but serious expert opinion are also submitted, from someone who has visited the site several times and examined the structure of the snow on the given slope. He rules out any kind of avalanche in this area!

I have not seen any data showing that documented avalanche cases have occurred on this slope in the last 60 years! What are we talking about?

Your comment about the difference in snow conditions shown by the pictures digging up the tent site and the picture of the found tent is very good! The origin of the pictures digging up the tent site (there are two such pictures) is completely uncertain. They do not appear on any inventoried film negatives! In these pictures, one of the hikers can be recognized by his clothing. But what proves that these pictures were taken on this tour? It is also possible that the pictures were really taken on this tour, and we can really see them digging up the last tent site, but this site is different from the site that shows the tent found - because the tent was moved by someone.

Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ramsay on October 13, 2026, 04:24:27 AM
Bongyi, a conventional avalanche was impossible to occur that night, And a plate avalanche, although rare, is something that could have happened. Although I don't believe it's plausible that a plate avalanche occurred in the tent, it's impossible that Zolotarev and Dubinina were injured there.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 14, 2026, 03:24:58 PM
There has been a debate about where the tent actually was. This is important of course because the slope changes accordingly. Many of us contend that the location of the tent coincides with a depression in the earth which, in winter would fill with snow. This snow could be leveled for the floor is the tent it also changes the angles for snow pile up and a small scale slide outside the tent.

The reality is the tent was cut from inside. There is no satisfactory explanation for such an action unless it involves respiratory distress.  There was nothing in the case files mentioning residue nor odor. The rescue photo makes it clear the tent was under snow.

I am certain an act of Nature forced them out. We need no plots, scandals, nor killers to explain a natural occurrence. Of course those other things sell books.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 14, 2026, 04:56:27 PM
Why have these compelling forces of nature not been reproduced in the last 60 years? Or if they do, where is the documentation about them? E.g, avalanches are not like they happen once and then never again! They happen regularly, often according to a schedule!
Belief in a very special natural conjunction, which is only it happened on 1959 February 1-2 and since then it has never happened again, no better than the wildest conspiracy theory!

The phenomenon causing the abandonment of the tent is either unspecified; or the assumed cannot be reproduced; and there is no data on repeated occurrences from the last 60 years.
So this is a completely unlikely thing! But it in no way explains the injuries, because then the bodies could not have been in 1.5 km distance.
It follows from this that the previous extremely improbable event that caused the abandonment of the tent was not the only thing that hikers had to suffer that night, but that at least one more other tragic event had to happen, which caused their very different and difficult-to-explain injuries!

I think it's easy to see that the probability of two such unlikely natural events combining is very close to zero!
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 14, 2026, 05:51:33 PM
You can use the exact argument and substitute the assassin of your choice for avalanche. The result is identical. For what it's worth, I do not advocate for an avalanche. There are different degrees of mass snow movement, a avlanche being the largest,slab slip the smallest.

No need to import or invent spooks to disturb the DP9. Weather will suffice.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ziljoe on October 14, 2026, 05:59:10 PM
Why have these compelling forces of nature not been reproduced in the last 60 years? Or if they do, where is the documentation about them? E.g, avalanches are not like they happen once and then never again! They happen regularly, often according to a schedule!
Belief in a very special natural conjunction, which is only it happened on 1959 February 1-2 and since then it has never happened again, no better than the wildest conspiracy theory!

The phenomenon causing the abandonment of the tent is either unspecified; or the assumed cannot be reproduced; and there is no data on repeated occurrences from the last 60 years.
So this is a completely unlikely thing! But it in no way explains the injuries, because then the bodies could not have been in 1.5 km distance.
It follows from this that the previous extremely improbable event that caused the abandonment of the tent was not the only thing that hikers had to suffer that night, but that at least one more other tragic event had to happen, which caused their very different and difficult-to-explain injuries!

I think it's easy to see that the probability of two such unlikely natural events combining is very close to zero!

It's not as clear as that. Unlikely is a key word but how likely is it that it was a conspiracy given all the variables that have to come in to play?

Most years , no one is there and not every year can guarantee the same weather pattern. The main difference is that the hikers manipulated the snow layers to dig their tent foundation. That cut is also on a slope leaving a ledge where it might be possible to weaken the snow layer or build up of snow above . There's wind to factor in also.

Things can happen once , a small avalanche can occur and not be seen again. You would probably need to be there all winter , every winter for a hundred years to get a baseline of how the snowlayers build up and freeze, cutting a new trench every night with the hope that the snow and wind are the same as the night of the incident.

It's a plausible theory and not impossible that there was a collapse of snow but not in the size or imagination of what you see on TV. Enough to fill the trench . Igors jacket was stuck in a hole towards the slope , or so it is reported, close to the entrance where the other jacket was found hanging. This alone suggest some sort of breaking of the tent canvas and an attempt to block something, wind or snow?.

Some of us think the injuries are done at the tent and others don't, those of us in favour of some sort of snow slide disagree on this and the type avalanche.

A collapse of snow at the snow den is probably the cause of the major injuries and I think that can overlap and work with a number of other theories.

Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 14, 2026, 06:46:53 PM
For what it's worth, I do not advocate for an avalanche. There are different degrees of mass snow movement, a avlanche being the largest,slab slip the smallest.


Are there documented slab-slip cases from the last 60 years on that slope?  Could anyone reproduce a slab-slip at the supposed location of the tent? If so, which place was considered the location of the tent? Where is the documentation on this?
If not, how does this slab-slip differ from an avalanche for that slope?
There are no documented slab-slip cases and no documented avalanche cases.
No one could reproduce slab-slip in the supposed location of the tent, and no avalanche was reproduced.  Everything is the same, whichever one we are talking about.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 14, 2026, 07:33:45 PM
@Ziljoe

There are several tours there every year. No avalanche v. slab-slip has ever happened to anyone. It is disputed on scientific grounds that any kind of snow movement could develop there at all!

Puzrin and Gaume say that slab-avalance should occur 7.5 - 13 hours after digging the tent site. If the Gyatlovs dug the tent between 5 and 6 p.m. Then the avalanche must occur after 1 o'clock at night, when they are already asleep. 
My question: Why is there no entry in the common diary on February 1?  Because they every day wrote in the diary. Were they going to bed without a diary entry on the very day the tragedy happened?  This is another factor that brings the probability of the avalanche theory even closer to zero!

But that's still only one of the main parts of it. As I explained, in order for the injuries to occur, at least another natural disaster must happen to them! 

The probability of natural disasters forcing you to leave the tent and causing injuries occurring in one night is so small that this narrative cannot be taken seriously.

In addition, hikers suffer different injuries. And their corpses are far from each other. Based on which we have to assume that injuries are not suffered jointly due to another natural disaster, but that new accidents happen to everyone in separate groups. Collapse of snow, anything that causes serious injuries (everything from burns to multiple rib fractures) and then freezes. 
The combination of the occurrence of so many tragic misfortunes cannot be imagined! That doesn't happen. Totally unlikely!

You are trying to fit childish theories on mutually exclusive and contradictory facts!  Oh man, for 60 years, everyone has failed!
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ziljoe on October 14, 2026, 09:18:41 PM
@bongyi

I don't agree with Purzin and Gaum , at least not on everything. They are applying a model and giving you the science , within the scientific community and others , it is an accepted plausibility. Allegedly the slope above the tent is over 30 degrees in areas.

I think it can be taken seriously, academics and avalanche experts take it seriously and they are far more educated than I about such matters.

I accept that you believe that it wasn't an avalanche, please put your theory forward.

I think you should write a paper on your evidence and get it published then that would show the experts and scientific that it's impossible and childish .

Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 14, 2026, 10:02:21 PM
@Ziljoe

A question has been asked, hasn't it. And there was no answer from you.  It looks like you always do this!
I'll post it again, differently!
So, from the fact that there is no entry in the common diary on February 1st  [and neither do the individuals diaries], can we conclude that there is no entry because they have to leave their tent before they can start writing the diary?
And if that's the case, can Puzrin and Gaume's slab-avalanche, which supposedly arrives after one o'clock at night, hit no more than one empty tent?
You understand the chronological problem, right?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ziljoe on October 15, 2026, 03:02:11 AM
@Ziljoe

A question has been asked, hasn't it. And there was no answer from you.  It looks like you always do this!
I'll post it again, differently!
So, from the fact that there is no entry in the common diary on February 1st  [and neither do the individuals diaries], can we conclude that there is no entry because they have to leave their tent before they can start writing the diary?
And if that's the case, can Puzrin and Gaume's slab-avalanche, which supposedly arrives after one o'clock at night, hit no more than one empty tent?
You understand the chronological problem, right?

@sherlock bongyi Holme's

You got me. Although you keep editing your post's to different arguments.

Unfortunately I don't think it tells anything. I would like to think that they would have updated their diary in the tent but they couldn't do it outside for obvious reasons. It might just have been too cold or they were waiting for later or warmth for the fingers. I'm a bit surprised that there's no comment for the morning as they built their labaz there may have been an opportunity by a morning campfire .

So , it is a possibility that they were driven out early evening, or they just didn't bother to write it in the confined tent, or ......the incident happened at any where from 5pm to 9am , even that's a guess.

You understand that we can't tell the chronology of a snow collapse or when they might write their dairy, right?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 15, 2026, 10:33:08 AM
I think if you had to forum in my native language, you would also edit your post!

The Gyatlovs were experienced hikers and strong. It is unlikely that a natural phenomenon killed them! They would have endured all natural phenomena, or they would have avoided the situation in the first place!

For the other tour group, the Blinov group, their tent caught fire and was destroyed on the second day, and they went through the tour without a tent and did not turn back!  You can imagine the fortitude required for such a decision and the knowledge that they will survive any natural phenomenon.  When they arrived in Ivdel at the end of the tour, they were presumably not in very good condition! There they learn of Gyatlov's group's disappearance and immediately report to the search team and head back into the cold! Please take this into account when evaluating the position of hikers against the forces of nature!

The Gyatlovs had the preparation to avoid natural dangers and the ability to survive those that occurred!

They didn't undress in the cold of their own free will!

# edit:
Sorry! I mixed it up! Blinov would not return as a seeker until April.  I mixed it with an Atmanaki group. They join the search engines from that group. The tour is only 9 people and a few days. But the search-rescue is a lot of people and two months! This is a much bigger dose!
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ziljoe on October 15, 2026, 11:21:17 AM
Your English is fine , please do not worry about it, original content is more useful than retrospective changing the script . Imagine if that had been done to the case files?

I now see a pattern in your thinking, a couple of points. They didn't lose the tent entirely and they dug snow holes as many of the other hikers did. Plus they had sleeping bags and fires. So I'm not sure how or why you have the comparison , no two groups are the same and many have perished in winters over the Aisa land mass , including Mansi , military and locals.

Hikers are not super heros against forces of nature , if you lose your tent, clothes and equipment, and no ability to build a fire , then the odds become heavily stacked .

You will need more than your comparison unfortunately.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 16, 2026, 10:12:26 AM
It is interesting to mention that the Hungarian language is part of the Finno-Ugric language family and thus Hungarian and Mansi are language relatives.
I studied the Mansi words written down in the hikers' diaries, but I didn't find them familiar. However, the word “Холат” from the name of the mountain is a Mansi word, very similar to the Hungarian version: “halott” - it means dead.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Hunter on October 18, 2026, 11:27:32 AM
Bongyi, on Russian-language forums, discussed the photo of the tent being pitched. Indirect evidence that the Dyatlov group was spotted there includes felt boots tucked under the flap of one of the backpacks, just like those worn by one of the hikers. Additionally, the man on the far left in the photo has a protrusion near his waist that resembles a knife in a sheath on a free sling, like Krivonischenko's.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 18, 2026, 12:30:34 PM
@Hunter

And can't you imagine that this picture is from a previous tour by Krivonischenko?
1955 winter; November 1956; 1957 winter - he has tours from before that can be considered! Also, there may be non-registered tours! Based on the number of backpacks and skis, the picture could have been taken on this tour!
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Hunter on October 18, 2026, 08:23:47 PM
A couple more Dyatlov group members were identified there. And if we assume that this photo is from a different expedition, how did it end up in the search engine's archive?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 19, 2026, 03:22:15 AM
No more people can be validly identified from the pictures!
What is the exact path of these two images? Where do they appear first?  Why can't we know this?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ziljoe on October 19, 2026, 03:45:14 AM
The two photos of them making the snow platform and trench are in the case files .
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Hunter on October 19, 2026, 08:15:13 AM
Please indicate the page of the criminal case where these photographs are located.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Osi on October 19, 2026, 09:10:55 AM
Even if we were to assume that these photographs belonged to a different expedition, [Dp 9] must have traveled with different people. No one has claimed that this image pertains to another trip or that one of the individuals conducting the excavation was him. What these pictures make clear is that—even if it wasn’t DP—pitching a tent on a barren slope was not such a surprising occurrence after all; provided, of course, that it had been attempted on another occasion.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Hunter on October 19, 2026, 11:20:39 AM
Hiking reports contain instances where groups stopped in treeless areas. These stops were divided into two types:
1. Planned, but in this case the group had enough firewood for the night.
2. Unplanned (emergency) due to deteriorating weather conditions.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ziljoe on October 19, 2026, 12:21:06 PM
Please indicate the page of the criminal case where these photographs are located.

381 or 385.

"In one of the cameras the last frame shows the moment of excavation of snow for the installation of the tent. Considering that this frame was shot with an exposure of I/25 seconds, with a diaphragm of 5.6 at a film sensitivity of 65 Un. GOST, and taking into account the density of the frame, we can assume that the hikers started the installation of the tent around 5 pm 1.II.59. A similar picture was taken with another camera"
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Hunter on October 19, 2026, 12:39:45 PM
Is there a photo attached to the criminal case materials? Or is there just a description of a certain photo?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Ziljoe on October 19, 2026, 12:56:46 PM
Is there a photo attached to the criminal case materials? Or is there just a description of a certain photo?

That is part is what is written in  case file 385. I'm sure you can see what is in the case file.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 19, 2026, 04:01:36 PM
What Ivanov brings together here, I think it is worth accepting with doubt!

The fact that it determines from the film sensitivity, the brightness of the lens, and the exposure time at what time the picture was taken! Wow! Ivanov could only read this from a Aghata Christie's novel !  This is nonsens!

When mounted, all cameras were single and set equally.  Is it the same lens, is it the same exposure time?

Or are the camera settings and lenses different and does Ivanov know which camera the picture was taken with?

Ivanov knows how photosensitive film-negative this image was recorded!

Ivanov knows that the two pictures come from different cameras.

I remember that there was an incident: when the cameras are found, one of the cameras is taken  by a searcher and when it turns out, he has to return it, along with the film and photos.

Ivanov hands over the film negatives to the searchers for develop. (with this Ivanov commits a crime)

The two images in question do not appear on any known negatives.

In summary: You can see that something is wrong with the pictures! There is a problem with these two pictures in particular! Ivanov fantastically determines what time the picture was taken; Ivanov hands over film negatives to civilians; known images and negatives are different.

My assumption is that the tent was found earlier. The films in the cameras were developed and censored. After the censorship, the indifferent and harmless images were copied back to new film negatives using a photographic process and put back into the cameras. This is how they will be found on February 26.

Ivanov hands over the film negatives to the searchers for develop because he is covering up their fraud. If the searchers call up the pictures, no one will be able to accuse the authorities of making the pictures disappear, right? Otherwise, handing over evidence to civilians would be a crime! Especially in the case of film negatives, there is a risk that they could be destroyed during development, and then the images on them, which could even show the solution to the case, will be lost forever! A prosecutor couldn't risk that! But in fact, he doesn't risk anything, because they already have all the pictures, more than what is on the censored negatives, which the search engines will call up. The two pictures of the dig were censored pictures! Why? Because it refers to the location of the tent! At the time when the film exchange was made, there was no final version of how the authorities would falsify the events. It wasn't yet certain that they would want the tent to be on the mountainside.

There is still the possibility that these images were taken at a different time. Even if they were in the camera from before on the film reel. Thus, these were not the last pictures on the film negative sheet, but could have been somewhere in front. Although a good argument against this is what @Osi said, that no one came forward, that these pictures were taken at a different time and elsewhere, which tour he took! My answer to this is that the person does not know the picture from before, because it was only developed now, on the other hand, he cannot claim that I am there in the picture, because only Krivonischenko can be recognized. But I admit that @Osi's argument on this is pretty strong!

When it was decided what the final official narrative would be for the case, i.e. that the tent would be on the mountainside, the pictures were used to prove it. And they didn't care about the contradiction that these images are not on the negatives developed by the search engines!

The most suspicious thing is that Ivanov gives evidence to civilians!
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 19, 2026, 05:11:42 PM
Follow the money. Who profits from such an elaborate fiction? Who would care anyway? The truth is that bad things happen to good people. Conspiracy buffs do not have all the facts and certainly not the connections. Between the two imagining connections is easier than ignoring or inventing facts.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: amashilu on October 20, 2026, 03:04:45 AM
Follow the money. Who profits from such an elaborate fiction? Who would care anyway? The truth is that bad things happen to good people. Conspiracy buffs do not have all the facts and certainly not the connections. Between the two imagining connections is easier than ignoring or inventing facts.

There are certain phrases that you use repeatedly. One of them is "Follow the money." Could you explain what you mean, please?

Are you referring to more recent times where people write books or make pay-to-view videos?  Or are you talking about the event itself? If so, "follow the money" is a phrase that suggests there was some nefarious, back-alley, Russian Mafia deal going on, that someone was getting paid to .......... to what? Kill the hikers? How does "follow the money" fit into this event?
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 20, 2026, 07:49:43 AM
Thank you for your interest in my post. When I say, " follow the money", it comes from my observing patterns of people who advance themselves by using money as a tool.  All behavior is motivated. Money is a powerful motivator. Those motivated by money gain wealth, fame, or anonymity. Beneath that, it makes them feel good.

In the DPI, money buys assasins. Money buys coverups. Money pays for revenge killings. Additionally, money comes from commercial re tellings of an old hiking disaster where the mundane is replaced by the sensational. Emotional currency is a thing too. Defending a point of view which is paid in friendship with someone who is in a stronger position of influence. Think of Huxley as Darwin's bulldog analogy.

When we look back to the historical events, the causes and results of the incident can be understood as the result of decisions made in unforgiving weather.  Only later do we find people unsatisfied with that. This, of course leads to the classic. Who,what,when, why set of questions.

Every single conspiracy theory is founded on somebody being rewarded for their successful efforts to remove a source of irritation. If it is paid assasins, who pays them? If military, who gets to keep their rank or get promoted? If it is a grudge, then there is a paper trail. Etc.etc.

Imagining a conspiracy is easy. It is the invisible glue that connects factual links in the chain of events. Proving the conspiracy devolves into knowing who benefits from it. The beneficiary is also the banker. Follow the money to the banker and the reason becomes clear. All the rest is mundane detail. The longest journey begins with a single step.



Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Senior Maldonado on October 20, 2026, 08:22:08 AM
Quite unusual approach. As snow slab and cornice collapse are indifferent to money, it were them who caused DPI.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 20, 2026, 08:37:10 AM
In that sense, there is no difference between a conspiracy or anything else! In general, we must assume some kind of advantage as a motive for any action. This advantage is conceivable in many ways and it does not make sense to refer to it as money. And it's not a conspiracy-specific thing at all



When we look back to the historical events, the causes and results of the incident can be understood as the result of decisions made in unforgiving weather.  Only later do we find people unsatisfied with that. This, of course leads to the classic. Who,what,when, why set of questions.

E.g, the relatives soon talked about a missile accident. Obviously, chronologically, ideas appear earlier that are easier to imagine : an avalanche or murder. But from the fact that Lyuda's father talks about the missile accident in the police report, when the 5s are found, but his daughter is not yet there, it is clear that they were forced to assume something else from the beginning, and they did not find what happened to be explained at all by the harsh weather - unlike you.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Hunter on October 20, 2026, 08:53:22 AM
Ziljoe
Quote
That is part is what is written in  case file 385. I'm sure you can see what is in the case file.
The criminal case file doesn't contain the photograph Ivanov cites. Moreover, it doesn't contain a single photograph taken according to the regulations of the time. The exception is Churkina's forensic analysis. Therefore, the photograph in question is a big question; we can only assume, with a very high degree of certainty, that it's the one where certain figures appear to be digging a hole for a tent.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 20, 2026, 11:37:20 AM
Maldanado makes my point and Bongi thinks of currency only as money.

To put it is another light think altruism. That is doing a deed without the prospect of reward or recognition after doing somebody a favor. The DP9 were not candidates for a mercy killing.

If you insist on a point of view which covers up the deaths, I advise you to follow the  money. In conspiracies there is always a beneficiary. No exceptions.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: Hunter on October 20, 2026, 12:03:10 PM
In our case, we must also consider the peculiarities of the Soviet political system, where every negative development was swept under the rug, meaning it couldn't be used in political and ideological confrontation. Therefore, some emergency situations could be kept under wraps, just in case. The same thing happened here: the Dyatlov affair could have negatively impacted the ruling party's image, and if necessary, it could have been spinned as a political affair.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 20, 2026, 12:35:22 PM
Hunter, thanks for reinforcing my point. By suppressing the hiking incident and lopping off a few administrative heads, so to speak, a price was paid for the deadly incident.This happened irrespective of the cause, which I contend was stormy weather. This face saving move served to deflect responsibility from the Soviet administration and protect the security, prestige and power of  those who could be removed for political reasons. In short, they still get paid.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: amashilu on October 20, 2026, 01:16:20 PM
If you haven't seen the movie about the Chernobyl disaster, it's enlightening in its depiction of the Russian govt's need to present itself as perfect at all times and never admit a mistake .....  allowing radiation to leak into Europe without telling or warning anyone just so their perfect facade was not tarnished. What radiation? Nothing to see here, everything is perfect. I believe it was Sweden who first noticed high radiation rates and started an investigation. It would not be out of character at all for the Russian govt. to have treated the troubling DPI incident in the same way. But I don't think "follow the money" is relevant here because there is no reward, only anxiety and hush-up.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 20, 2026, 02:18:52 PM
This is a good example. My interpretation is that the discovery and remediation of the Chernobyl meltdown was very, very costly. The cover up was costly, the reveal was costly and the remediation is costly. Who paid for it and who suffered because of it? The incomplete answer is it was just the Soviet citizenry.

Back to the DPI. Everyone knows I advocate for this as a natural disaster, pure and simple. What most do not appreciate is I have given the necessary  tools to conspiracy buffs. The tools do not work themselves, but they work every time. They are 1. All behavior is motivated 2.Follow the money. 3. The "how" does not explain "why". 4. Truth and logic are not synomous. 5. Evidence must be valid and reliable.

Conspiracy buffs can use the tools I have provided. They will eventually come to the  singular conclusion they do not know all the facts. Then,they make them up. Some people honestly want to get at their version of the truth. They want to be paid for it in reputation, or publishing royalties. Neither is criminal, but as we well know that is not the whole story.

If it helps, think of money as,currency and think of currency as not just money.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 20, 2026, 02:53:45 PM
@GlennM
I lived under a Soviet-style administration and I assume @Hunter did too! I have direct experience of how this system works!

The Gyatlov incident cannot be interpreted separately from the Soviet administration.

We knew about Chernobyl right away. I live in a neighboring country.  My mother worked in an institute where the increased radiation was immediately registered. It wasn't dangerous for us, the wind wasn't blowing towards us. We were lucky. But we knew much earlier than it was announced on the news.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 20, 2026, 06:27:57 PM
What is the point you are trying to make? Is it that Soviet leaders want to keep their power and wealth? Follow the money .They wished to keep their moneg and power by blaming someone else. It was no conspiracy to destroy Chernobyl. It was hubris, or conceited pride that started the problem.

You claim the power plant failure was no secret and soon detected. When it was revealed, did any Soviet leader throw himself on his ceremonial sword as a sacrfice for his sin? No! Everyone scrambled to protect their self interest and blame someone else.

Did you note that in the DPI, did this behavior happen? Yes it did and the director of the Sports Club was removed. Was he blamed for a conspiracy? Assasins? Rocket crash? No. There was no conspiracy, only an accident of Nature and a scape goat at the UPI.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: SURI on October 21, 2026, 12:19:57 AM
Did you note that in the DPI, did this behavior happen? Yes it did and the director of the Sports Club was removed. Was he blamed for a conspiracy? Assasins? Rocket crash? No. There was no conspiracy, only an accident of Nature and a scape goat at the UPI.

Yet, Ivanov chose him and one more person from the entire list—even after 30 years!—and named them as the ultimate culprits of the entire incident. They kept silent, they kept quiet, and they profited from it. Surely you understand what that implies. And if it were even remotely possible, they would have been arrested.


Here is the key source:

"But there were those for whom silence was beneficial. First of all, the director /or whatever his name was/ Gordo was silent. He was one of the culprits of the detachment making a lot of mistakes. The head of the city sports committee /I don't remember his last name/ was silent, because he was also guilty of the detachment being "semi-wild", moving into the stage of "wildness" at the final stage.

I was quite surprised that at the bureau these two absolutely guilty people in the death of the guys were slightly punished, I think they were given a reprimand. And this meant that it was impossible to bring them to criminal responsibility, because They were members of the CPSU, and until very recently, until 1986, the Instruction of the Central Committee of the CPSU and the instructional letter of the Central Committee of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks) and the Council of People's Commissars of the USSR, signed by Stalin and Molotov in 1939 on the issue of eliminating serious distortions in the fight against enemies of the people, were in effect. This letter said that many cases of unjustified prosecution of people were allowed at the local level, abuses were allowed in the NKGB and NKVD bodies in this matter, and it was proposed that a member of the All-Union Communist Party (Bolsheviks) could be brought to criminal responsibility only with the consent of the party committee, and he could be arrested only with the personal sanction of the first secretary. /only the first secretary wrote a resolution and the seal of the district or city committee was put on it/. So, the city and regional committees did not give such consent to bring these two people to justice. And that's it, the issue is resolved."


That is not how you talk about a scapegoat!
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: bongyi on October 21, 2026, 08:38:19 AM

Yet, Ivanov chose him and one more person from the entire list—even after 30 years!—and named them as the ultimate culprits of the entire incident. They kept silent, they kept quiet, and they profited from it. Surely you understand what that implies. And if it were even remotely possible, they would have been arrested.

No just Ivanov, but Lyuda's father also accused these people. I think Ivanov is trying to divert attention from his own responsibility.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 21, 2026, 11:49:04 AM
The elephant in the room is one of interpretation. The DP9 were not deliberately sent to their death any more than the Blinov group was. Finding a fall guy comes next.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: sarapuk on October 28, 2026, 02:38:04 PM
Yes, that is one of the reasons why I do not agree with the slab avalanche theory. We need to determine whether the phenomenon that caused the evacuation of the tent was the same as the one involved in the events further down the slope. So, why did they head in the opposite direction from Labaz—and against the freezing winds? (What kind of drive and determination motivates people to venture into the darkness and the unknown?)

Well, the answer is probably that they were scared of something. Even terrified. Phenomenon is a good word to use. Indications are that the event at the tent was linked to the event down the slope and in the forest and the ravine.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: sarapuk on October 28, 2026, 02:41:09 PM
They were on a slope. The slope led,to trees. Trees are shelter, firewood and a snow cave. No other decision produces the same risk to reward.

Except that they fled their abode not properly dressed or equipped for those extreme weather conditions. They must have been scared or even terrified of something in order to do that.
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: sarapuk on October 28, 2026, 02:49:15 PM
Why have these compelling forces of nature not been reproduced in the last 60 years? Or if they do, where is the documentation about them? E.g, avalanches are not like they happen once and then never again! They happen regularly, often according to a schedule!
Belief in a very special natural conjunction, which is only it happened on 1959 February 1-2 and since then it has never happened again, no better than the wildest conspiracy theory!

The phenomenon causing the abandonment of the tent is either unspecified; or the assumed cannot be reproduced; and there is no data on repeated occurrences from the last 60 years.
So this is a completely unlikely thing! But it in no way explains the injuries, because then the bodies could not have been in 1.5 km distance.
It follows from this that the previous extremely improbable event that caused the abandonment of the tent was not the only thing that hikers had to suffer that night, but that at least one more other tragic event had to happen, which caused their very different and difficult-to-explain injuries!

I think it's easy to see that the probability of two such unlikely natural events combining is very close to zero!


Well put. Obviously, we have to take into account that most events of whatever nature are always going to be unique. No 2 events will be the same.


Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: sarapuk on October 28, 2026, 02:53:16 PM
For what it's worth, I do not advocate for an avalanche. There are different degrees of mass snow movement, a avlanche being the largest,slab slip the smallest.


Are there documented slab-slip cases from the last 60 years on that slope?  Could anyone reproduce a slab-slip at the supposed location of the tent? If so, which place was considered the location of the tent? Where is the documentation on this?
If not, how does this slab-slip differ from an avalanche for that slope?
There are no documented slab-slip cases and no documented avalanche cases.
No one could reproduce slab-slip in the supposed location of the tent, and no avalanche was reproduced.  Everything is the same, whichever one we are talking about.


Also, as I mentioned recently, there have been plenty of expeditions to the Dyatlov Pass since the incident, and none of them has encountered snow conditions that could cause an avalanche. 






Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: sarapuk on October 28, 2026, 02:58:33 PM
Follow the money. Who profits from such an elaborate fiction? Who would care anyway? The truth is that bad things happen to good people. Conspiracy buffs do not have all the facts and certainly not the connections. Between the two imagining connections is easier than ignoring or inventing facts.

Follow the money? I wonder how many investigators in this Forum are interested in making money out of it? Probably not many, if any. 
Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: sarapuk on October 28, 2026, 03:02:30 PM
Thank you for your interest in my post. When I say, " follow the money", it comes from my observing patterns of people who advance themselves by using money as a tool.  All behavior is motivated. Money is a powerful motivator. Those motivated by money gain wealth, fame, or anonymity. Beneath that, it makes them feel good.

In the DPI, money buys assasins. Money buys coverups. Money pays for revenge killings. Additionally, money comes from commercial re tellings of an old hiking disaster where the mundane is replaced by the sensational. Emotional currency is a thing too. Defending a point of view which is paid in friendship with someone who is in a stronger position of influence. Think of Huxley as Darwin's bulldog analogy.

When we look back to the historical events, the causes and results of the incident can be understood as the result of decisions made in unforgiving weather.  Only later do we find people unsatisfied with that. This, of course leads to the classic. Who,what,when, why set of questions.

Every single conspiracy theory is founded on somebody being rewarded for their successful efforts to remove a source of irritation. If it is paid assasins, who pays them? If military, who gets to keep their rank or get promoted? If it is a grudge, then there is a paper trail. Etc.etc.

Imagining a conspiracy is easy. It is the invisible glue that connects factual links in the chain of events. Proving the conspiracy devolves into knowing who benefits from it. The beneficiary is also the banker. Follow the money to the banker and the reason becomes clear. All the rest is mundane detail. The longest journey begins with a single step.

It looks like you use the term follow the money for anyone who doesn't believe that bad weather caused the Dyatlov tragedy.


Title: Re: 2 Chinese lanterns
Post by: GlennM on October 29, 2026, 08:16:23 AM
I say it because it works. The reason why conspiracy theories fail is because nobody can satisfactorily demonstrate who derives benefit, nor what the benefit is and confirm it. They do not have all the facts.  What they do consider as factual are second and third hand reminisces and imaginings. A natural disaster circumvents all that voodoo. Nothing needs to be added, nor subtracted to it. It is just a matter of working out the timeline.

I contend that Igor sustained injury to his ankles which slowed the group progress on Feb 1. They made camp short of there they would have liked to on 1079. Foul weather an a localized slide covered their shelter which necessitated cutting. They moved deliberately to the woods. They underestimated the difficulty and distance. They divided up, some to dig a shelter, some to gather wood for ground cover and some to tend a fire. Because they were not dressed for it, there were accidental falls which were unrecoverable. There was also a collapse of their temporary shelter. The few survivors attempted to retreat to home but could not do so. All attributable to inclement weather.