And why even being on the forum - where all the information is available: you write about fakes and cast a shadow on Russian forensic experts.
P.S. These photos were hardly taken by G.E. Churkina/Makushkina herself. Most likely - the first to visit the scene - her colleague from the Sverdlovsk NICL: Mikhailova Taisiya Ivanovna.
You wrote "most likely", that is to say you are not sure? Anyway, the most beautiful part is the drawing, which will remain as a standard.
The Soviet forensic "experts" didn't need anyone to dishonor them, they were perfectly capable of doing it themselves... as they did in Katyn for example, exhuming their own victims and writing a travesty of a report they tried to impose at the Nuremberg trial. They obeyed orders and if they didn't, they knew it was the end of their careers, if not of their lives. And in 1959, the Soviet biological sciences were still under the influence of Lysenko...you've heard of Lysenko, haven't you?
I'm always astonished to see how people can imagine that the USSR in 1959 was a civilized country like Switzerland or Sweden, and not the totalitarian state ruled by a man who personally sent 30,000 of his fellow countrymen to be shot in the head.
А причем тут Лысенко, если Вы действительно разбирали его роль в науке СССР? Вы постоянно предлагаете какой-то винегрет из малосочетающихся продуктов/фактов.
Причем тут судебная медицина и её эксперты - к повествованию о экспертах-криминалистах? Медицина и криминалистика состыковались в одну специальность гораздо позднее. На 1959 год - это разные профессиональные предметные области знаний и разное подчинение. Так - на этот период времени во всех странах.
Сын Чуркиной/Макушкиной неоднократно давал пояснения, что от своей матери знал что она была в Ивделе только один раз - в мае 1959 года. Больше из штата сотрудников НИКЛ на 1959 никого нет чтоб подходил по специализации и опыту. Только Михайлова Т.И.
В книге Ю.Е. Ярового "Высшей категории трудности", которую Вы разумеется не пытались читать, а она была написана автором который попал на поиски буквально в день обнаружения трупов. Так вот в этой книге дан портрет криминалиста который осматривает палатку в кабинете прокуратуры Ивделя. Ю.Е.Юдин, которого привлекали к опознанию, подтверждал что был в этом кабинете и помогал развешивать палатку туристов на гвоздиках.
Чарльз, Вы совершенно и очевидно не пытались изучить тему, а просто бродите в своих представлениях. Причем весьма неглубоких и ненаучных. Вы могли бы сначала изучить положение дел в таких историях для своей страны. Вы же не станете утверждать, что во Франции не было ни трупов, ни следствия, ни криминалистов. Можете поизучать истории других стран, где тексты есть на английском. Похожая история была в Финляндии. Тоже палатка и тоже трупы, туристы и криминалисты. Гуглите сами, чтоб выбрать читаемый текст:
Убийство на озере Бодом — убийство, произошедшее в Финляндии в 1960 у озера Бодом, расположенного около города Эспоо в 17 км от Хельсинки
https://ru.frwiki.wiki/wiki/Meurtres_du_lac_BodomAnd what does Lysenko have to do with it, if you really analyzed his role in the science of the USSR? You constantly offer some kind of vinaigrette from incongruous products / facts.
And what about forensic medicine and its experts - to the story of forensic experts? Medicine and criminology joined into one specialty much later. For 1959, these are different professional subject areas of knowledge and different subordination. So - for this period of time in all countries.
The son of Churkina / Makushkina repeatedly gave explanations that he knew from his mother that she was in Ivdel only once - in May 1959. There is no one else from the staff of NICL for 1959 who is suitable for specialization and experience. Only Mikhailova T.I.
In the book by Yu.E. Yarovoy's "Highest Category of Difficulty", which of course you did not try to read, but it was written by an author who went on a search literally on the day the corpses were discovered. So, in this book, a portrait of a forensic scientist is given who inspects a tent in the office of the Ivdel prosecutor's office. Yu.E.Yudin, who was involved in the identification, confirmed that he was in this office and helped to hang up the tent of tourists on carnations.
Charles, you have absolutely and obviously not tried to study the topic, but just wandering around in your ideas. And very shallow and unscientific. You could first study the state of affairs in such stories for your country. You will not begin to assert that in France there were no corpses, no investigation, no criminalists. You can study the history of other countries where the texts are in English. A similar story was in Finland. Also a tent and also corpses, tourists and criminologists. Google yourself to select readable text:
Bodom Lake Murder - a murder that took place in Finland in 1960 near Lake Bodom, located near the city of Espoo, 17 km from Helsinki
Topic: Tent: how many photos to make one photo? (Read 15549 times)